Carlauren collapse shows it’s not just investors who suffer

With a few exceptions, investors in collapsed unregulated investment schemes generally find sympathy in short supply.

The media will occasionally print the hard-luck story of a someone who invested their entire pension lump sum, or an injury compensation payment, but the news cycle usually moves swiftly on.

And the general public’s opinion of people who invest too much money in collapsed unregulated investments is often that they were some combination of greedy (even though the idea that all collapsed schemes were “too good to be true” is a total myth), naive, or too tight to consult a regulated financial adviser.

This is not a view shared by this blog; anyone who gets the impression that we lack empathy for the position of investors in failed investments has not understood why Bond Review exists.

Those who parrot thought-terminating clichés like “a fool and his money are soon parted” might pause for a change to consider the plight of elderly residents in Carlauren’s care holmes.

In June, as Sean Murray’s empire built on promises to pay investors 10% a year collapsed around his ears, elderly and vulnerable residents at Tyndale House were told they had a month to find alternative accommodation.

As if this wasn’t distressing enough, on 2 July, the same day Carlauren COO Andrew Jamieson was confronted by unpaid staff, the residents were told this deadline had been accelerated to 24 hours. According to Bond Review reader cpnorfolk:

Social Services had to find emergency accommodation for the residents. My sister managed to get my mother into the care home she was due to transfer to. They were able to fit her in a week early, but it was utter pandemonium on the day and very distressing for all.

Another reader, Jps, says:

Due to non-payment of staff, the residents were put at risk. These risks were presented to senior management prior to closure yet they choose to ignore them. Residents had just 4 hours to find somewhere else to live. Staff continued to work really hard with the help of social services to ensure that this was done with as much dignity as possible. However no-one can compensate for the distress and heartbreak this caused those elderly residents and staff members.

According to ITV News, residents of sheltered housing owned by Carlauren were left without on-site support as a knock-on effect of the closure of Tyndale House. Carlauren said at the time they “have been working hard to ensure they receive the care and support required”.

The fact that the collapse of Carlauren’s unregulated investment scheme left a number of elderly care home residents as collateral damage is more than an unfortunate accident.

The purpose of the financial system is to move money from where it is to where it is needed.

The purpose of financial regulation is to ensure that it does so as efficiently as possible, with a minimum of waste. When this system goes wrong, people’s money is not used to bring economic benefit, but the opposite.

If, hypothetically, I take £5 million off a bunch of investors claiming I’m going to pay them 8% per year for investing in property development, and use £1 million to pay some architects and builders to build the skeletons of a few buildings, knowing it has virtually no chance of ever seeing completion because the scheme will run out of money long before, it is not just the investors’ £5 million which has been lost.

It is also a waste of the architects’ and builders’ time which could have been spent building something that actually had a chance of seeing the light of day.

Economists talk of “the multiplier effect”, which means that when somebody spends money to buy stuff, whoever they buy it from pays their workers and themselves, who buy more stuff, and so on. Economic activity generates more economic activity.

Unfortunately the multiplier effect also applies to economic damage.

The failure of duff investments leaves not just investors with empty pockets but abandoned building sites, wasted resources and in this case, distressed elderly residents.

Had Carlauren not been able to raise money directly from retail investors on promises of 10% per year, it is highly unlikely that it would have been able to purchase Tyndale House and other care homes. Institutional investors were unlikely to hand over money because a guy fresh off the back of the failure of a scheme involving the sale of distressed properties in Detroit had decided to try his hand at looking after the elderly.

The complacent idea that the collapse of unregulated investment schemes doesn’t matter because it only affects “fools and their money”, which has allowed the Government to leave UK securities law stuck in the 1920s, needs to be re-examined urgently.

A billion pounds is at risk of loss in unregulated investment schemes that solicited investment from the public and entered administration in 2019. This is not just a loss to the investors but to the UK economy as well.

Anyone home?

4 thoughts on “Carlauren collapse shows it’s not just investors who suffer

  1. Finally someone highlighting the affect this has had on people other than investors.
    The residents of Tyndale house, who many sold their homes to pay for their care and support and a safe service. They did not recieve this despite the dedication and commitment of unpaid staff and was told to leave the premises within 4 hours as a result. How and why this has not been raised as a safeguarding concern and Sean Murray made accountable for serious financial abuse is beyond me. Some staff are still owed thousands of pounds despite the government helping out with their capped redundancy payment service. Leaving hard working dedicated workforce in financial hardship. Who have now been left high and dry and ignored completely by the administrators Quantama. There are too many victims involved not just the investors. this is not that I lack sympathy for them, I just think this should have been looked at as a whole with everyone that has been affected. Too many serious issues have been overlooked and as far as I’m concerned Sean Murray has not been held accountable for anything and will continue to live the high life and start all over again. There has been no one protecting or representing the residents of Tyndale or the staff.

    Liked by 1 person

  2. Thank you. A concise review of the situation, I have only ever felt sorry for those affected. I live opposite one of their failed investments and what was once a thriving attractive hotel is now an overgrown building site right on the sea front.

    Like

  3. Victims of scams are lied to by those happy to take advantage of them.

    But we can all be persuaded by those willing to lie to further their own interests at your expense and tomorrow (12th Dec 2019) millions of people will become such victims when they vote for the liar they considered was the most “believable” … depending on who wins will determine just how much you will be “scammed” by the state over the next 5 years ….

    Like

  4. What really surprised me that the agents who sold this ponzi scheme to investors are now filing to get their unpaid commissions. They are the first one who should be held accountable for selling this fraud, missing due diligence and failing to advised for a committed criminal who is now free to start all over again with missing million hidden in some offshore bank account

    Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s